Bilder Wikicommons

1. Copyright
1. Gissar att du har koll på API:et....
   
   Jag gjorde en test jsfiddler med Litteraturbanken se http://jsfiddle.net/salgo60/oxtuy9rL
   
   Copyright kollar du på tackoverflow tycker dom
   
   https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7453654/retrieving-image-license-and-author-information-in-wiki-commons
   
   att du frågar per bild dvs.....

Links

• Denny Vrandečić kort om detta med en strikt ontologi eller fördelen med öppen/flexibel vid 59:00 min "Wikidata Turns 6: A Special Interview with Denny Vrandečić
• Classify sources t=2450
• Simplicity t=3708
• Should Wikidata be the hub t=2855
• Wikibase t=2942
• Maturity of the project t=3153
• What is the tradeoff of a stricter ontology t=3543
• Is Wikidata the semantic dream
• We are not decentralized
• We are not selfdescribing
• to flat
• Wikidata, Knowledge Graphs, and Beyond
• 8.5 million SPARQL daily  t=461
• SPARQL federation 
• #ATMs around Munich belonging to the Bankcard-Servicenetz interbank network (federated query)
• Expressivity
• länk ISWC keynote Jamie Taylor Google "Applied semantics: beyond the catalog"

• One to one principles
• The Programming Historian
• Using SPARQL to access Linked Open Data
• 32:50 SWIB18 talk by Karen Smith-Yoshimura

Metadata check in Swedish on digital curated sources

EARLY DRAFTI did some metadata check on the following Swedish sources

• Karl XII
• SMVK-EM at kulturarvsdata 
• Gustav II Adolf 
• kulturarvsdata.se
• kulturnav.org
• Sockendräkt Digitalt museum
  
  

I feel we lack a good linked data vision compare our winning linked data vision 2016

1. is moving around objects with bad metadata a good strategy
    
2. is aggregation to Europeana the solution
    
3. is playing with User interfaces adding some value? or is bad metadata  always bad metadata  that makes our experience less good
   
   Is bad metadata like a museum with closed doors......
    
4. what is the impact of having Swedish culture with bad metadata and a weak stategi and modelling knowledge...
5. Digisam started in 2012 speaking about linked data since then the following reports/blogposts has been produced
1. TBA
2. Linked data and the future of aggregation
3. 2015 06 Digisam recommends that persons working on digital cultural heritage aim to follow the star model formulated by Tim Berners-Lee,
4. 2014 Utvärdering av samordningssekretariatet för digitalisering, digitalt bevarande och digitalt tillgängliggörande (Digisam)
1. Statskontoret kan konstatera att samordningen inom Digisam hittills har haft begränsad påverkan på hur de enskilda institutionerna bedriver sitt interna digitaliseringsarbete.
5. .....
6. Interesting initiatives
1. Ksamsök/RAÄ
1. started in 2008?!?!  with LOD but....
1. Miss platforms for communication i.e. 
1. you can never track issues/change requests
2. I have not seen any Linked Data vision its more delivering Strings in RDF
1. What we see is people travelling around on conferencies and like each other on twitter (50 000 tweets or more)
2. They yearly create hackathons but feels  no outcome see my winning linked data vision 2016
2. If you ask semantic questions they feel offended I guess its more an indication they are outside the safety box
    
3. People doing in Linked data is more programmers han domain experts is my feeling
    
4. Reports success is done in numbers of objects with bad metadata that are moved to Europeana an aggregation services with a very weak metadata model....
5.  The story told is we have good linked metadata and used Linked data since 2013
   
2. Digitalmuseum
1. Has a linked data concept that every museum is responsible for its links and people/places qualified as authorities
1. my feeling is that the system is more a place grouping uploaded objects than good metadata
2. The RDF ontology is very weak compared with Wikidata and feel like museums dont even understand how connect things in a more advanced way....
3. when asking  "adding a person" I got a no see  link
3. Riksarkivet
1. Tora
4. LIBRIS Linked data Libay
1. LIBRISXL

Metadatacheck SMVK-EM at kulturarvsdata Karl XII

see Comments Magnus below

• Summary
• Tweet
• carlotta-em/web/object/1843478
• SMVK-EM/name/1843478

Wikidata Karl XII (Q52934) GRAF

kung av Sverige 1697–1718

• 92 påståenden
• 70 webbplatslänk
• 55 external links
• Wikidata Q52934
• properties english
• swedish
• chinese 
• arabic
• Wikidocumentary
• Swedish
• English
• Chinese
• Arabic
• Alvin alvin-person:25751

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?>
<rdf:RDF xmlns:rdf="http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"
         xmlns:ns0="http://kulturarvsdata.se/ksamsok#"
         xmlns:owl="http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#">

  <rdf:Description rdf:about="http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/name/1843478">
    <rdf:type rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/ksamsok#Entity"/>
    <ns0:ksamsokVersion>1.1</ns0:ksamsokVersion>
    <ns0:serviceName>name</ns0:serviceName>
    <ns0:serviceOrganization>SMVK-EM</ns0:serviceOrganization>
    <ns0:buildDate>2019-10-20</ns0:buildDate>
    <ns0:url>http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/object/1843478</ns0:url>
    <ns0:subject rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/Subject#culturalHistory"/>
    <ns0:dataQuality rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/DataQuality#raw"/>
    <ns0:itemSuperType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/EntitySuperType#agent"/>
    <ns0:itemType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/EntityType#person"/>
    <ns0:itemLabel>Karl XII</ns0:itemLabel>

Comment 1 Magnus: language just Swedish should also be all spoken languages in Sweden and languages spoken by tourists atleast
This is normally available to download from Wikidata hat is CC0
<ns0:itemLicense rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/License#cc0"/>
    <ns0:itemLicenseUrl rdf:resource="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"/>
    <ns0:itemDescription>
      <ns0:ItemDescription>
        <ns0:type>Beskrivning</ns0:type>
        <ns0:desc>Karl XII, född den 17 juni, g.s. (27 juni, n.s.) 1682, död den 30 november, g.s. (11 december, n.s.) 1718, var kung av Sverige från 1697 till sin död. Han är tillsammans med Gustav II Adolf Sveriges mest kände &quot;krigarkung&quot;. Han var son till Karl XI och Ulrika Eleonora d.ä., bror till Ulrika Eleonora d.y., samt kusin till August den starke, Fredrik IV av Danmark och Fredrik IV av Holstein-Gottorp (se vidare Anfäder nedan).

Karl XII kallades även Järnhuvudet, Karl den oövervinnerlige samt Lejonet i Bender. Den engelska författarinnan Edith M. Almedingen gav sin omfattande biografi titeln The Lion of the North''[1] (&quot;Nordens lejon&quot;), vilket är samma tillnamn som Gustav II Adolf en gång fick. (wikipedia, 2011-03-28)</ns0:desc>
      </ns0:ItemDescription>

Comment 2 Magnus: freetext that should be structured information and available in more languages
</ns0:itemDescription>

    <ns0:itemDescription>
      <ns0:ItemDescription>
        <ns0:type>Tidpunkt / födelse</ns0:type>
        <ns0:desc>1682-06-17</ns0:desc>
      </ns0:ItemDescription>
    </ns0:itemDescription>

Comment 3 Magnus: Date without calendar format see earlier comment
<ns0:itemDescription>
      <ns0:ItemDescription>
        <ns0:type>Tidpunkt / död</ns0:type>
        <ns0:desc>1718-11-30</ns0:desc>
      </ns0:ItemDescription>
    </ns0:itemDescription>

    <ns0:itemKeyWord>Carl XII</ns0:itemKeyWord>
    <ns0:itemKeyWord>LSH:Karl XII</ns0:itemKeyWord>

Comment 4 Magnus: Keywords as text could be an entity and also support more languages
<ns0:itemName>
      <ns0:ItemName>
        <ns0:type>Visat namn</ns0:type>
        <ns0:name>Karl XII</ns0:name>
      </ns0:ItemName>
    </ns0:itemName>

    <ns0:itemNumber>
      <ns0:ItemNumber>
        <ns0:type>Libris-id / samma som</ns0:type>
        <ns0:number>213500</ns0:number>
      </ns0:ItemNumber>
    </ns0:itemNumber>

Comment 5 Magnus: LIBRISid could be the new LibrisXL id link Wikidata says LIBRISXL is 42gjkkvn5dpdxzp

Comment 6 Magnus: odd not having a specific tag for LIBRIS




    <ns0:itemTitle>kung</ns0:itemTitle>
    <ns0:name>Carl XII</ns0:name>
    <ns0:firstName>Carl</ns0:firstName>
    <ns0:firstName>Karl</ns0:firstName>

Comment 7 Magnus: does he have 2 first names or is it alternative spellings. No llanguage tag

<ns0:context>
      <ns0:Context>
        <ns0:contextSuperType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/ContextSuperType#create"/>
        <ns0:contextType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/ContextType#start"/>
        <ns0:fromTime>1682</ns0:fromTime>
        <ns0:toTime>1682</ns0:toTime>
      </ns0:Context>
    </ns0:context>

    <ns0:context>
      <ns0:Context>
        <ns0:contextSuperType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/ContextSuperType#cease"/>
        <ns0:contextType rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/ContextType#stop"/>
        <ns0:fromTime>1718</ns0:fromTime>
        <ns0:toTime>1718</ns0:toTime>
      </ns0:Context>
    </ns0:context>

    <ns0:thumbnail>http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/image/tn/2102524/image.jpg</ns0:thumbnail>
    <ns0:image>
      <ns0:Image>
        <ns0:thumbnailSource>http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/image/tn/2102524/image.jpg</ns0:thumbnailSource>
        <ns0:lowresSource>http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/image/zoom/2102523/image.jpg</ns0:lowresSource>
        <ns0:mediaLicense rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/License#pdmark"/>
        <ns0:mediaLicenseUrl rdf:resource="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/"/>
        <ns0:copyright>Utgången upphovsrätt</ns0:copyright>
        <ns0:byline>Krafft, David von</ns0:byline>
      </ns0:Image>
    </ns0:image>

    <ns0:isVisualizedBy rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1509400"/>
    <ns0:isVisualizedBy rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1509404"/>
    <ns0:isVisualizedBy rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1842999"/>
    <owl:sameAs rdf:resource="http://kulturarvsdata.se/LSH/agents/16906"/>
    <owl:sameAs rdf:resource="http://libris.kb.se/resource/auth/213500"/>
    <owl:sameAs rdf:resource="http://kulturnav.org/f23c0769-7342-493c-bddf-c0580cd86e20"/>
    <ns0:isDescribedBy rdf:resource="http://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_XII"/>
    <ns0:presentation rdf:parseType="Literal">
      <pres:item xmlns:pres="http://kulturarvsdata.se/presentation#">
      <pres:version>1.1</pres:version>
      <pres:entityUri>http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/name/1843478</pres:entityUri>
      <pres:id>1843478</pres:id>
      <pres:organization>Statens museer för världskultur - Etnografiska museet</pres:organization>
      <pres:organizationShort>SMVK-EM</pres:organizationShort>
      <pres:service>name</pres:service>
      <pres:dataQuality>Rådata</pres:dataQuality>
      <pres:buildDate>2019-10-20</pres:buildDate>
      <pres:idLabel>213500</pres:idLabel>
      <pres:itemLabel>Karl XII</pres:itemLabel><pres:type>Agent</pres:type><pres:description>Karl XII, född den 17 juni, g.s. (27 juni, n.s.) 1682, död den 30 november, g.s. (11 december, n.s.) 1718, var kung av Sverige från 1697 till sin död. Han är tillsammans med Gustav II Adolf Sveriges mest kände "krigarkung". Han var son till Karl XI och Ulrika Eleonora d.ä., bror till Ulrika Eleonora d.y., samt kusin till August den starke, Fredrik IV av Danmark och Fredrik IV av Holstein-Gottorp (se vidare Anfäder nedan).

Karl XII kallades även Järnhuvudet, Karl den oövervinnerlige samt Lejonet i Bender. Den engelska författarinnan Edith M. Almedingen gav sin omfattande biografi titeln The Lion of the North''[1] ("Nordens lejon"), vilket är samma tillnamn som Gustav II Adolf en gång fick. (wikipedia, 2011-03-28)</pres:description>

Comment 8 Magnus: text without language tag ha maybe should be properties. Date 1682 is seven times in the text and n.s. maybe should be translated to calenderformat used
<pres:description>1682-06-17</pres:description>

<pres:description>1718-11-30</pres:description>
<pres:context>
   <pres:event></pres:event>
   <pres:timeLabel>1682</pres:timeLabel>
</pres:context>
<pres:context>
    <pres:event></pres:event>
    <pres:timeLabel>1718</pres:timeLabel>
</pres:context>
<pres:image>
     <pres:mediaType>image/jpeg</pres:mediaType>
     <pres:src ="thumbnail">http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/image/tn/2102524/image.jpg</pres:src>
     <pres:src ="lowres">http://collections.smvk.se/carlotta-em/web/image/zoom/2102523/image.jpg</pres:src>
     <pres:mediaLicense>http://kulturarvsdata.se/resurser/License#pdmark</pres:mediaLicense>
     <pres:copyright>Utgången upphovsrätt</pres:copyright>
     <pres:byline>Krafft, David von</pres:byline>

Comment 9 Magnus: David von Krafft should be an entity same as Q586719

</pres:image>
<pres:references>
     <pres:reference>http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1509400</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1509404</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/objekt/1842999</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://kulturarvsdata.se/LSH/agents/16906</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://libris.kb.se/resource/auth/213500</pres:reference><pres:reference>http://kulturnav.org/f23c0769-7342-493c-bddf-c0580cd86e20</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_XII</pres:reference>

Comment 9 Magnus: maybe something more like same as
<pres:reference>http://carlotta.malmo.se/carlotta-mmus/web/object/841612</pres:reference>
     <pres:reference>http://kulturarvsdata.se/LSH/agents/html/16906</pres:reference></pres:references>
     <pres:representations><pres:representation ="HTML">http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/name/html/1843478</pres:representation>
     <pres:representation ="XML">http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/name/xml/1843478</pres:representation>
     <pres:representation ="RDF">http://kulturarvsdata.se/SMVK-EM/name/rdf/1843478</pres:representation></pres:representations>
  </pres:item>
  </ns0:presentation>
  </rdf:Description>

</rdf:RDF>